Author: Nick Andrews
Publish Date: Summer 2008
Carrot rust flies (Psila rosae
) are well known to growers of carrots, parsnips, celeriac, celery and other umbelliferous crops. The adult females are attracted to the odor of the host plant, and lay their eggs at the crown of the plant. The adults don’t do any damage, but after the eggs hatch, larvae immediately burrow into the soil and start feeding on the roots. As the larvae grow, the amount of damage they cause increases. Recently planted crops can be killed resulting in stand thinning. After forming a tap root, more mature carrots, parsnips and celeriac suffer direct crop damage from the tunneling larvae (figure 1). The lower stems of celery are normally only damaged when populations are somewhat higher. The larval excrement or frass is rust colored, giving the flies their common middle name, and is deposited in the tunnels.
In Oregon the first generation adults are active from mid April to June. Larvae feed on roots starting in May and June with the subsequent second generation adults emerging in August and September. Late second and early third generation adults are active at the same time with the second generation adults lasting into October. Crop damage accumulates over time.
The activity of adult flies can be monitored with yellow ticky traps available from various suppliers including Great Lakes IPM (800-235-0285) and Gempler’s (800-382-8473). Three traps are normally placed at the edge of the field nearest the previous carrot or parsnip crop and near any shelter belts. Researchers in the UK have shown that trap counts are increased when traps are set at a 45º angle (figure 2). Commercial growers sometimes use the traps to schedule insecticide sprays, or to find the best time to remove row covers.
Thresholds vary depending on the market tolerance for damage, and the cost of control measures. It is difficult to predict damage levels from the number of adults caught in traps, but a widely used monitoring service in the UK recommended that protection should start when 2-3 flies are caught per field in one week, and should continue until counts decline.
The sticky traps are not specific to carrot flies, and there are some non pest flies that have a similar appearance. Figure 3 shows an adult carrot fly on a trap. They have clear wings, a shiny black thorax and abdomen with few hairs, an orange head with dark red eyes and translucent orange legs. With a bit of experience, the combination of these features makes it relatively easy to distinguish carrot flies from the other species trapped.
Currently available pesticides are unlikely to provide acceptable control of large populations, so cultural
methods for managing local populations are important for organic and conventional growers alike. Since carrot rust flies are relatively weak flyers, populations tend to be localized. Populations decline the further away susceptible crops are from the previous overwintering host crop. Flies probably travel less than 1000 yards in search of egg laying sites. The adults are attracted to the smell of a host crop and fly upwind towards the smell. Isolation of crops from previous years’ fields can significantly reduce carrot fly risk, especially when the new crop can be placed downwind of the previous crop (figure 4).
If crops can be planted after most of the first generation adults have died (late May to early June), the second generation infestations will be lighter. This doesn’t hold true for adjacent sequential plantings since an early planting would support the first generation, and the second generation adults could fly to the later planting. Early harvest can also reduce the risk of damage from maturing second generation larvae and overwintering third generation larvae. Cull piles and overwintered carrots and parsnips can be a significant source of flies and should be managed accordingly. In recent conversations with carrot and parsnip growers we have started to speculate that trap crops may help reduce populations in an area. Our hypothesis is that if a couple rows of an attractive crop were planted in the previous years’ field, it would attract a large proportion of the first generation flies, especially if the current years’ crop is situated as far away as possible, and preferably downwind. After the first generation flight is over, the trap crop should be completely destroyed, then a few weeks later the process could be repeated with the second generation flies. To our knowledge, this method has been untested.
Organic growers have few available insecticides. Some formulations of spinosad, neem, natural pyrethrum and other materials are allowed for use on organic farms. Some of these products may have some efficacy, but remain largely untested in the Pacific Northwest. Conventional growers often use diazinon at planting and zeta cypermethrin (Mustang) during the season. Mustang is only effective against adults and to be effective, egg laying should be minimized. Therefore, it is prudent to time sprays with trap counts.
Small organic farms sometimes control carrot flies with row covers. To be effective, crops should be covered as soon as they emerge whenever carrot flies are active. Special attention should be paid to keeping the crop covered and the edges of the row cover secured. As already mentioned, sticky traps can be used to determine periods of low adult activity when row covers can be removed with little risk of damage. If flies are allowed to lay eggs before a crop is covered, the larvae and subsequent generations will be trapped under the row cover and are capable of causing substantial damage.
An integrated approach to carrot fly management is critical for both organic and conventional farmers. Whenever possible it is helpful to work with neighbors to reduce the overall population in your area. Feel free to contact Nick Andrews if you would like help monitoring carrot flies or would like to discuss the most promising management strategies for your farm.